Home
1
News
2
News
3
* A Global Force to Handle COVID-19 with Flu Control Protocols is Required4
http://www.hsvg.org/ Guahan Global Foundation
Guahan Global Foundation P.O. Box 206, Hagatna, GU 96932, USA
(October 21, 2024) A thorough review of the worldwide COVID-19 pandemic response is needed When Mr. Edward Lu, our Director of Public Health Office and the President of Guahan Global Foundation, was preparing his monthly column in the Guam Daily Post and thinking of the Breast Cancer Awareness Month, he found a CBS News report telling Morgen Chesonis-Gonzalez’s story. She, an art therapist in Miami, skipped her annual screenings when the COVID-19 pandemic swept the globe and people stayed home and kept their distance. After persistent pain in her armpit forced her to schedule a mammogram later in the year, the hospital found she had two forms of breast cancer. When the oncologist told Morgen the result, her husband was actually “listening in” from the car, not physically being with her. During her chemotherapy sessions, Morgen sat alone in the hospital, unable to have someone by her side because of pandemic restrictions. When she needed a bilateral mastectomy, she went into the hospital alone again. When there was an oncology meeting, her husband continued to join it by phone, taking notes in the hospital’s parking lot. It’s very likely that Morgen wasn’t the only case experiencing the hardship. An original investigation result published in JAMA Network Open on January 21, 2021, showed that 41% of US adults reported forgone medical care from March to mid-July 2020, the initial phase of the COVID-19 pandemic in the US. When researchers looked at data from those who reported needing care during those months, 58% of people surveyed missed scheduled preventative care. Some of them might be shocked by the diagnosis they heard after their medical arrangement returned to normalcy and had to undergo treatments alone, much like what Morgen suffered from. While the World Health Organization is calling “No one should face breast cancer alone” as the theme of 2024 Breast Cancer Awareness Month, we would like to call for thorough reviews of the worldwide COVID-19 pandemic response in order to facilitate better systematic measures in the future when the next public health crisis comes, making sure no one needs to face difficulties alone again. In fact, the editors of The Economist had written in September 2020 that, when COVID-19 struck, many governments were taken by surprise and pulled the emergency brake. However, treatments and medicines were making COVID-19 less deadly. New vaccines would soon add to their effects. Yet it was here, in the basics of public health, where too many governments were still failing their people. They had to do better. The Economist pointed out one problem at the time, which was the desire to escape a trade-off between shutting down to keep people alive and staying open so that life goes on. Their editors emphasized that blanket lockdowns that most countries implemented were costly and unsustainable. In contrast, Germany, Taiwan and South Korea used fine-grained testing and tracing to spot individual super-spreading venues and slowed the spreading with quarantines. Quite a number of public health experts had advised before COVID vaccines became available that the human society was inevitably going to live with the coronavirus for a while and only sustainable measures would help everybody get through the pandemic. Unfortunately, most governments, with certain high-profile scientists and celebrities, put too much faith in lockdowns, ignoring the basics of public health and just waiting for vaccines. They gave the public the wrong expectation that COVID vaccines would work perfectly like a silver bullet. After so-called “breakthrough infections” emerged although vaccines rolled out, people feared virus exposure even more seriously. A case report published in the New England Journal of Medicine on January 30, 2020 has informed the world that Germany’s first two infected people contracted COVID-19 from a colleague who flew in from Shanghai to join a company workshop. Soon after, two other colleagues, who had not had contact with the Chinese visitor, tested positive for the coronavirus. The cluster showed how the coronavirus was transmitted from human to human — very similar to an influenza virus — and COVID-19 only caused mild flu-like symptoms. As of February 29, 2020 Singapore reported 93 cases, including five clusters, and quite a few patients whose source of infection could not be traced. Those numbers showed that the coronavirus could spread easily within a community, just like an influenza virus. Excluding the cruise ship cases, Japan confirmed more than 250 cases by February 2020. Most of those infected only had flu-like symptoms, while six older patients died of pneumonia. So, in Japan, the coronavirus spreading also looked like a flu epidemic, with elderly people more likely to have a severe illness and to die. As for the frighteningly high death tolls in China and Italy in the early months of the pandemic, it’s very likely to result from collapsing healthcare systems, where too many people were rushing to hospitals for treatment, a scenario usually seen in severe flu-like epidemics.  However, most people appeared too nervous to notice the COVID-19’s “flu-like” pattern as they rushed into lockdowns and did not consider other options. The biggest myth is that lockdowns are the only solution when an epidemic worsens. In fact, a lockdown is a measure to cordon off a seriously affected place so that people in surrounding areas are protected. When SARS hit Taiwan in 2003, local health authorities locked down a hospital with a nosocomial, or hospital-acquired, infection to protect the neighboring community. When Wuhan became the epicenter of China’s COVID-19 outbreak in January 2020, authorities issued a lockdown order to prevent the virus from spreading to other cities and provinces. Italy misunderstood the lockdown measure and became the first country in Europe to enforce a lockdown, starting in the north and then spreading nationwide. But on March 19, 2020 it also became the first country having a death toll that surpassed China’s. Belgium rushed into a lockdown as well, and forgot to take care of at-risk older people. As of the end of April 2020, 53% of Belgium’s 7,703 deaths occurred in care homes. Belgium officials admitted that, because of poor preparation, care home staff lacked personal protective equipment and, unfortunately, allowed the virus to spread quickly. In addition to tragedies happening to many individuals, lots of social-economic impacts are still giving some communities a hard time about returning to pre-pandemic normality. For example, Guam Visitors Bureau recently reported that visitor arrivals to Guam during the first 11 months of fiscal 2024 only represented 47% of pre-pandemic 2019 levels. We certainly understand research on the pathogen takes time and epidemic control can’t wait when facing an emerging new disease. However, the only pragmatic move is to find clues through a quick epidemiological analysis of reported cases to form a proper action plan, instead of rushing into a chaotic response. Hopefully, we all learned lessons from COVID-19 pandemic and the world’s leading countries and international organizations will prepare a better global health network before the next crisis comes. Mr. Lu's column titled "One one should face difficulites alone" has been published in the Guam Daily Post on October 19, 2024. http://www.hsvg.org/hot_501608.html * A thorough review of the worldwide COVID-19 pandemic response is needed 2024-10-21 2025-10-21
Guahan Global Foundation P.O. Box 206, Hagatna, GU 96932, USA http://www.hsvg.org/hot_501608.html
Guahan Global Foundation P.O. Box 206, Hagatna, GU 96932, USA http://www.hsvg.org/hot_501608.html
https://schema.org/EventMovedOnline https://schema.org/OfflineEventAttendanceMode
2024-10-21 http://schema.org/InStock TWD 0 http://www.hsvg.org/hot_501608.html

Home ﹥ News > News > * A Global Force to Handle COVID-19 with Flu Control Protocols is Required

(March 16, 2020)


A Global Force to Handle COVID-19 with Flu Control Protocols is Required


As COVID-19 is becoming a global issue, most people seem too nervous to notice that the virus is actually showing its flu-like epidemic pattern while more countries reported more cases around the world. Based on the pattern observed, the epidemic could be ended if an international organization steps forward to coordinate a global force to thoroughly implement flu control protocols in most of countries as soon as possible.



f990413b083054f50c6e8a880c2e6c28.JPG


In the end of January, Germany’s first two cases contracted the virus from a colleague who flew in from Shanghai to join the company’s workshop, and then another two colleagues who did not contact the Chinese visitor were tested positive as well soon. This cluster has preliminarily showed the human-to-human transmission of the virus could be very easy, and very similar to what the flu virus does. At the same time, those German patients’ very mild flu-like illness was noticed.



Singapore and Japan offered significant evidence of a larger scale in February. As of February 29, Singapore reported 93 cases, including five clusters and quite a number of patients whose source of infection is not known. It was showing that the spread of the virus could easily happen in the community, exactly like what the flu virus can do. And, just like those German cases, patients in Singapore were fighting with flu-like symptoms only, no severe cases reported.



Excluding the cruise line’s cases, Japan had found more than 250 cases in different cities and prefectures in February. Most of infected people had flu-like symptoms only and six elderly patients died from pneumonia. So, in Japan, the virus was also showing a flu-like epidemic, which usually brings senior people a higher risk of severity and fatality.



In addition, A BMJ, originally called British Medical Journal, article published on February 18 offers evidence from comparison of case fatality rate (CFR), which is the ratio of deaths from a certain disease to the total number of people diagnosed with this disease for a certain period of time representing a measure of disease severity. SARS had a CFR of around 10%. MERS killed 34%. COVID-19’s overall CFR was around 2%. A collaboration of Hong Kong University and Harvard University also estimated the CFR of COVID-19 is around 1.4%.



Therefore, the COVID-19 virus turns out to be mostly causing flu-like illness only. It does not seem to be a SARS-like or MERS-like super killing bug of the new decade. The scaring death toll number in China could be the result of a medical system collapse caused by too many patients rushing into hospitals, which is the scenario we usually saw during a flu pandemic. So, countries with increasing death tolls, such as Italy and Iran, need international aids.



Although The CFR number of COVID-19 mentioned above is lower than SARS’s and MERS’s, most experts agree the CFR of a seasonal flu is around 0.1% only. Therefore, we still have to take the virus seriously, most importantly, with a right strategy.



Based on its flu-like epidemic pattern, the goal of a global response to COVID-19 should change from containment to mitigation, for example, helping the elderly and people with underlying health conditions to avoid death tragedies. Don't waste resources on finding asymptomatic infections. Make sure that medical institutions are ready for a huge amount of patients. Remind Healthy people to wash hands more often and sick people to stay home. Besides these, Taiwan’s recent experience shows that wearing a mask is an effective extra precaution.



Excluding three small clusters with the index case contracting the virus in January, Taiwan did not report any new domestic case after January 31 until a local woman was tested positive on February 28. Besides washing hands, it is worth to notice that the majority of Taiwanese have been promptly wearing a mask since the epidemic started scaring people in the beginning of January, even though many experts claimed that wearing a mask is not necessary at that time. Although the shortage of surgical masks had caused chaos, the chaotic situation is believed to become a reminder of having most Taiwanese practice good personal hygiene all the time, which is the main preventive measure before we have vaccines and new drugs.



The researches on the virus take time and epidemic control can’t wait. It is necessary to find clues through the epidemiological analysis on the reported cases to help form the proper response strategy. The best solution for now is to follow flu control measures strictly, including public education of good personal hygiene, home or institutional quarantine on sick people, and a flu surveillance network that asks clinics and hospitals to report patients with flu-like symptoms for further virus testing and early advanced treatment, plus a few extra precautions, such as wearing a mask and maintaining healthy immune defense, to carry everybody through. The world's leading countries should drive a force to push flu control protocols and call for all countries to move forward in the same direction for a sooner ending of the epidemic.

Previous Back to List Next